Five hours later, PBMCs were harvested and analyzed for CD107b an

Five hours later, PBMCs were harvested and analyzed for CD107b and IFNγ by flow cytometry. There was a minimal background (<2%) in spontaneous CD107b cell surface mobilization and IFNγ expression (Fig. 2B). In contrast, 7.7% of CD8+ cells harvested before

surgery degranulated and elaborated IFNγ in response to autologous tumor cells, revealing a pre-existing CTL response against the tumor. The frequency of IFNγ+CD107b+ CTLs increased to 24.5% by 37 days following surgery and intracavitary IFNγ gene transfer. The frequency of tumor-reactive CTLs increased with subsequent vaccinations, peaking at a 38% IFNγ+/CD107b+ CTLs measured 14 days after the third vaccination (Fig. 2B). In contrast to the CTL response, click here vaccination was not associated with any clear trend in the

percentage of CD4+Fox3P+ regulatory T cells in the peripheral blood (Fig. 2C) [29]. The majority of GemA patients will ultimately develop GBM and succumb to their disease despite surgery and adjuvant therapy [4]. Compared to the more aggressive GBM that has a median time to progression of 6.9 months [2], we propose that GemA is an attractive target for immunological therapies that may work more slowly and, potentially, more effectively in this earlier and less aggressive form of astrocytoma to induce tumor regression and anti-tumor immunity. This case PLX-4720 manufacturer report is not sufficient to make firm conclusions about the ability of the combination of IFNγ gene transfer and CpG/lysate vaccination to prevent progression of GemA to GBM, however the data do demonstrate that the therapy is feasible in a large animal model. Our results raise several interesting points that warrant attention. In the present study, the autologous tumor cells grew too slowly to generate adequate lysate after the first vaccination; therefore, we administered

allogeneic anaplastic astrocytoma lysate for the remaining four vaccinations. Interestingly, the first vaccination induced an IgG response Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase specific to two antigens in the autologous tumor sample that were approximately 50–65 kDa in molecular weight, as seen at day 51 (Fig. 2A). Vaccination with allogeneic lysate apparently primed a polyclonal IgG response to several other autologous antigens. While the identity of these IgG epitopes (or the T cell epitopes) was not determined, our results demonstrate that CpG/lysate vaccination is a feasible method to break immunological tolerance to multiple glioma antigens. Although preliminary, our data indicate that autologous tumor cell lysate production may not always be feasible in WHO II grade gliomas, but allogeneic WHO III grade lysates could be used as a scalable “off the shelf” antigen source. We are currently treating additional dogs to better define the logistics, efficacy, and safety of this therapy.

An additional three peptides—one each in ENV, POL, and VPR—elicit

An additional three peptides—one each in ENV, POL, and VPR—elicited positive responses in Mali only. The 27 epitopes chosen in 2009 were also assessed in ELISpot assays with five HIV-positive donors who were confirmed to be HLA-A2 negative. Four of the five donors (80%) had no positive IFNγ responses to any of the 27 peptides tested;

one donor responded to only one of 27 (3.7%) peptides tested, demonstrating HLA-A2 specificity of the peptides selected for our present study. For the cohorts of chronically HIV-1-infected subjects from both the Miriam Hospital and the clinic in Bamako, Mali, there was no clear association between viral load, CD4 T-cell count, or years of known HIV infection with responses to HLA-A2 Selleck LGK-974 epitopes. In addition, no clear association was found between having multiple A2 alleles and the number of epitopes that elicited a detectable IFNγ ELISpot result for a given donor. It is worth ZD1839 noting that, in general, the subjects from Mali had an impressive number of epitope responses compared to the Providence subjects (Table 3a–c). One patient in this group responded to 25 epitopes, and four others with low viral loads responded to a mean of eleven epitopes. It is possible that this is

due to the fact that these subjects were recruited for the study less than a year after they had been identified as HIV-positive and/or due to the correlate that none of the study participants in Mali had yet received long-term antiretroviral therapy. Notably, the one Providence subject (H_0865) who was not receiving ART, yet had a low viral load, responded to eight HLA-A2 epitopes. The ELISpot analysis reconfirmed eleven epitopes that were published for HLA-A2 prior to the time of selection for this study (Table 1). Five of the epitopes that were initially identified and predicted by our 2002 informatics analysis as entirely novel HLA-A2 epitopes have subsequently been validated as A2-restricted epitopes by others (Table 1). These epitopes are ENV-1004 (TMGAASITL) [65], GAG-1012 (RMYSPVSIL) [66], POL-1006

first (ALQDSGSEV) [67], POL-1247 (HLKTAVQMAV) [54], and VIF-1237 (DLADQLIHLY) [54]. Thus sixteen of the 38 epitopes have been validated by both our group and by other laboratories as HLA-A2 epitopes. In addition, assays confirmed five peptides that had been published epitopes prior to selection for inclusion in our study, although they were not published in the context of HLA-A2 (Table 1). Four of these epitopes were immunogenic in ELISpot assays with PBMCs from HLA-A2 subjects, and while only two of these epitopes were tested in in vitro binding assays, both bound to HLA-A2. The fifth epitope, POL-1016 (GLKKKKSVTV) [67], did not elicit positive IFNγ ELISpot responses in any subjects yet was shown to bind to HLA-A2 with low affinity, indicating that this may still be a relevant candidate for inclusion in a global vaccine (Table 1).

Thus, the addition of Bexsero® to an already busy vaccination sch

Thus, the addition of Bexsero® to an already busy vaccination schedule appears challenging, at least in the first 6 months of life, primarily due to widespread reluctance to administer three injections simultaneously and thus to administer Bexsero®

concomitantly Lapatinib with currently recommended standard vaccines. Moreover, 90% of pediatricians who objected to three simultaneous injections believed that parents would also object to this. A recent review of mostly North American studies on provider and parental attitudes towards multiple injections [23] showed that provider acceptance of >2 injections increased when official recommendations required this. Providers also tended

to overestimate parental concern, and reassurance by physicians as well as an understanding of the severity of the target disease increased parental acceptance of multiple injections. While parental objection to >2 injections per visit was also reported in a recent study from The Netherlands [24], with a majority of parents preferring an extra visit, half said they would probably accept three vaccinations if actually offered. Similarly, the Australian survey showed that a third injection per visit made only 15% of parents less likely to want MenB vaccine for their child [15]. However, none of the studies, including the latter, explicitly investigated whether Selleck VE-821 parental acceptance for concomitant

vaccination would be affected by the information that concomitant vaccination was shown to be more reactogenic than alternating injections. Taken heptaminol together, our results suggest that if STIKO should recommend MenB vaccination for infants from 2 months of age on completion of the evidence assessment, it would be essential to provide pediatricians with a convincing rationale and strong arguments for concomitant vaccination, to ensure successful implementation and to avoid the dropping of other equally or even more important vaccinations by physicians or parents. This should include evidence suggesting that parents can be convinced to accept three simultaneous injections by their physicians. Since MenB incidence is highest in the first year of life, with about half of cases occurring <6 months of age, early vaccination would prevent the most cases. Nonetheless, in Germany 59% of cases in the first 3 years of life occur in children aged 9 months and older, the age-span in which protection would be expected using the later 3-dose schedule. An additional 21% of cases in children <3 years of age occur in children from 5 to 8 months of age (unpublished data, Robert Koch Institute), potentially preventable through earlier vaccination.

Just over half of the girls were aware of cervical smear tests M

Just over half of the girls were aware of cervical smear tests. Most of these girls were also aware that in the future they would need to go for cervical smear tests themselves, although few knew at what age they would be first expected to attend for one. Most of the girls who knew about smear tests had learnt about them from their mothers, for example when their mothers had talked about receiving their own appointment cards for screening. It was also common for girls to recall that during their HPV vaccination school nurses

had told them they would still need to go for smear tests in the future. Some girls had heard that smear tests were unpleasant but were aware of its necessity. This seemed most evident when KPT-330 purchase they discussed Jade Goody’s untimely death and several groups discussed the fact that she had missed attending for a smear test which led to the late discovery of her cancer (FGS- E7, E8, E9, S4, S7, S11), as illustrated by the following

learn more extract: Anna: I think she [Goody] hadnae been for a smear or something. One of the issues that the girls seemed most keen to discuss was their experience of HPV vaccination. Whilst there were often silences and stilted conversation in discussion of their understandings about HPV infection and its prevention, conversation was animated and the girls frequently interrupted or spoke over each other when recalling their experiences of receiving the vaccination. This was particularly evident in relation to their fear of needles and the pain of injection, the issue of privacy during vaccination, and concerns about needle cleanliness. Across the focus groups, it was common for girls to discuss feeling scared about getting the vaccine and worried about the level of pain caused by the needle. This was discussed in all of the groups and ranged from girls describing a mild sense of nervousness, to feeling tearful or sick with anxiety. In four groups girls talked hypothetically about refusing the HPV vaccine due to what they described as ‘needle phobias’ Oxygenase but only one girl actually stated that she

had refused the vaccine because of a needle phobia. Girls frequently described difficulty controlling a range of emotions in front of class mates. As one girl described: “We were all standing waiting and the fear was building. Me and my friend were crying coz we didn’t want to get it. People were laughing at us. It weren’t funny. And afterwards, we saw them crying, so we were laughing then” (FG E3: Fran 14). In almost all of the groups there was also discussion of various myths and rumours circulating about the vaccination. These seemed to stem from the fact that three doses of the vaccine were required, and the prospect of three injections often became more daunting as rumours spread. Typical rumours were that each injection was more painful than the previous one, that the needle became larger with each dose, or that the dose became “thicker” and “larger”.

The current live attenuated vaccines induce a low VNAb titre in v

The current live attenuated vaccines induce a low VNAb titre in vaccinates after a primary vaccination course suggesting cell-mediated immunity plays an important role in clearance of AHSV infection in horses vaccinated with live attenuated or canarypox VP2/VP5 vaccines [6], [14] and [21]. In the mouse model both cell-mediated and VNAb responses were stimulated by MVA-VP2 vaccination, however EPZ-6438 manufacturer passive transfer experiments have shown that humoral immunity plays a critical role in protection against AHSV [12] and [22]. In the present study,

MVA-VP2 vaccination induced a relatively high VNAb titre compared to that induced by existing live attenuated vaccines, but cell-mediated immune responses have not yet been measured. In this study we have detected the presence of viral RNA, though at lower levels than in the control animals, in non-infectious blood samples from the vaccinated horses for up to day 21 post-challenge. The high virus challenge dose (107.4 per horse) given by the intravenous route, the natural capacity of AHSV to bind erythrocytes [23] and

the high sensitivity of RT-PCR techniques could explain the presence of viral RNA in the non-infectious blood of vaccinated horses. This is consistent with the findings obtained during the development of an RT-PCR diagnostic assay of AHSV in which viral RNA was detected from the blood of horses inoculated intravenously with 105.5 TCID50/ml up to day 97 post-infection [24]. It is very selleck chemical difficult to discern from our data whether AHSV RNA in the vaccinates was a result of viral replication in the host or not. Analysis of the antibody responses by the virus neutralisation test and by the VP7 ELISA test showed more than a four-fold increase in VNAb titre and these an increase in VP7 ELISA antibody levels in

paired serum samples collected at day 34 (challenge day) and day 62. This could be an indication of a low level of viral replication in the vaccinates but this could also be the result of an anamnestic response of immune animals to re-exposure to an AHSV antigenic stimulus. Alternatively, virus particles neutralised by serum antibodies, could still be circulating in the vaccinates and could have been the source of viral RNA detected by the RT-PCR assay. Further work is needed to elucidate whether MVA-VP2 vaccination induces a complete sterile immunity but from the results of our study this immune response was sufficient to abrogate AHSV infectivity and to prevent any clinical disease and pyrexia in horses challenged with a high dose of AHSV. This study has demonstrated that MVA vaccines expressing VP2 alone are capable of inducing protective immunity, showing that co-expression of VP5 or other capsid proteins is not essential for the induction of a protective response.

The interpretation, analysis and views expressed are those of the

The interpretation, analysis and views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of NICE. “
groups. Substantial numbers of eligible people did not participate in the interventions, selleckchem however those who are eligible but

do not volunteer, or who volunteer but do not provide data may be different from those who participate. Trial participants are less likely to be male, current smokers or within the lowest quartile of SES than non-participants or defaulters (Chinn et al., 2006 and Waters et al., 2011). Thus, our quantitative review findings may not necessarily be representative of the hardest-to-reach low-SES groups. Some of the methodological challenges in conducting mixed method reviews would also apply here, including conflicting data produced by different methods, the resource-intensive nature of this method and dependence on authors’ descriptions of interventions (Harden and Thomas, 2007 and Kavanagh et al., 2012). buy FK228 Contextual or cultural differences between data sources may also be a challenge (Campbell et al., 2011). A strength of this review was the inclusion of many types of evidence,

which allowed us to explore effectiveness findings in contextual detail and create explicit links between quantitative and qualitative evidence, using methods appropriate for the data (Harden and Thomas, 2007 and Kavanagh et al., 2012). This enabled us to identify gaps in the intervention evidence base and thus directions for future research

(Harden and Thomas, 2007). There remains limited evidence for the effectiveness of specific dietary and physical activity interventions implemented in low-SES communities and many specific barriers to and facilitators of behaviour change exist, which warrant consideration when developing interventions for low-SES populations. While some of these factors appear to have been addressed in the interventions reviewed here, the published evidence suggests that others have not been addressed to date. Overall, evidence on the effectiveness of community-based dietary and physical activity interventions is inconclusive. A range of barriers and facilitators exist, some of which were addressed by interventions and some of which require consideration in future research. The following are the supplementary Liothyronine Sodium data related to this article. Supplementary Table 1.   Search strategies and details of evidence sources for community-based dietary and physical activity intervention studies for low-SES groups in the UK, 1990–2009. The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest. Data was collected, analysed and written up by the authors and the funder had no involvement in the analysis, writing up or decision to submit the article for publication. This review was funded by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) for the purpose of informing public health development.

3) In contrast, however, among children aged less than 10 years,

3). In contrast, however, among children aged less than 10 years, the rates of medically attended shingles were much lower for the publicly available period of 2002–2010 than for either the years when vaccine was only available by private purchase (1999–2001)

or those of the pre-vaccine (1994–1998) period. Table 3 and Table 4 display results from this Poisson model. The effect of co-morbidities is much more pronounced Selleckchem EGFR inhibitor in the younger age groups than in the older age groups (Table 3). For males aged <10 years, the relative risk of shingles is 2.6 times higher for those with co-morbidities than for those without; this relative risk declines to 0.93 for the 65+ age group. There is a notably sharp decline in the rate of shingles for both females and males under the age of 10 years (Table 4). The annual percentage change of minus 10% represents an annual decrease in the shingles rate starting Selleck Dasatinib in and persisting through the public availability period (2002–2010). Prior to this, all age groups had similar trends with slightly increasing rates,

though females had higher annual percentage changes. A sensitivity analysis that included only first episodes did not change estimated parameters. This paper expands the data available on secular trends in shingles incidence by providing additional data from outside the United States. It thus captures data from a population for whom health care and chickenpox vaccination is universally publicly funded and which differs demographically from that of the United States [14]. Our study is population based and we used data from Alberta’s universal publicly funded healthcare system in our analyses. Thus selection bias due to direct financial

costs for health services does not affect our findings. We also have data for both the pre-vaccine era and for a longer period after public funding of chickenpox vaccine than for other reports from Canada [15]. In prior work, we described the epidemiology of medically attended shingles in Alberta between 1986 and 2002 [9]. As in our prior report, we find a continuing trend of increase in crude medically attended shingles rates that began in the pre-vaccine era. Concerns have been raised that chickenpox Bay 11-7085 vaccination programs might lead to a decrease in the hypothesized ‘immune boosting’ effect of exposure to wild virus [2]. One might thus anticipate that there would be an increase in shingles rates in the age groups representing older unvaccinated cohorts [3]. This pattern while present in the publicly available period was also present prior to vaccine licensure. We do not think that this trend would be explained by an increase in health service utilization over the period because the age-specific rates of health service utilization for both males and females in Alberta have been stable until 2010 when a decline was observed for all age groups of both sexes (Alberta Health, unpublished).

Treatment of A549 cells with 10 μM C-DIM-8 resulted in 74 46 ± 0

Treatment of A549 cells with 10 μM C-DIM-8 resulted in 74.46 ± 0.66%, 2.15 ± 0.35%, and 23.39 ± 0.75% of cells accumulating in G1, G2, and in S-phase respectively, whereas at 20 μM, C-DIM-8 arrested 81.66 ± 0.22% cells in G1, 2.21 ± 0.44% in G2, and 16.13 ± 0.29% in S-phase (Fig. 2C). The apparent permeability (Papp) of C-DIM-5 and C-DIM-8 under acidic conditions (pH 5.0 and pH 6.0) was investigated as a basis for their oral delivery (Fig. 3). At pH of 5.0 and 6.0 the Papp of C-DIM-5 was 1.12 × 10−7 cm/s and 1.11 × 10−7 cm/s respectively (Fig. 3A). The Papp of C-DIM-8 increased from 1.0712 × 10−7 cm/s at pH 5.0–1.11 × 10−7 cm/s at pH 6.0 (Fig. 3B). While there was no difference between the two Papp of C-DIM-5, the differences in the Papp of C-DIM-8 were not considered significant (p > 0.05). The Papp of C-DIM-5 did not change significantly at either pH of 7.0 or 8.0 ( Fig. Target Selective Inhibitor Library 3A) while Compound Library price that of C-DIM-8 increased significantly (p < 0.05) to 1.15 × 10−7 cm/s and 1.16 × 10−7 cm/s respectively compared to Papp at pH of 5.0 and 6.0 ( Fig. 3B). Assessment of size and shape characteristics of nebulized C-DIM-5 and C-DIM-8 formulations was done by determining their mass median aerodynamic diameter (MMAD) and geometric standard deviation (GSD) using ACI as depicted in material

and methods. As shown for nebulized C-DIM-5 and C-DIM-8 (Fig. 4A and B respectively), significant deposition of aerosol droplets were achieved on stages 4 through 6 of

the impactor. C-DIM-5 and C-DIM-8 formulations yielded particles with aerodynamic most capabilities for deep pulmonary deposition with MMAD of 1.92 ± 0.22 μm, GSD of 2.31 ± 0.12 and a MMAD of 1.84 ± 0.31 μm and GSD of 2.11 ± 0.15) respectively. Representative lungs (Fig. 5A) with tumor nodules (black arrows) are shown for mice treated with nebulizer vehicle as control, nebulized C-DIM-5, C-DIM-8 and their combinations with doc. Compared to control lungs (12 nodules, Fig. 5A-I), tumor nodules were decreased after treatment with doc (7 nodules, Fig. 5A-II), C-DIM-5 (5 nodules, Fig. 5A-III), C-DIM-8 (3 nodules, Fig. 5A-IV), C-DIM-5 + doc (2 nodules, Fig. 5A-V) and C-DIM-8 + doc (2 nodules, Fig. 5A-VI). Reduction in tumor nodules in all treatment groups were considered significant compared to control (p < 0.05). H&E staining of representative lung sections (Fig. 5B) also showed similar behavior. Evidence of tissue remodeling and migration are evidenced in control (Fig. 5B-I) by abundant nuclei foci. However, less pathology is evident in groups treated with doc ( Fig. 5B-II), C-DIM-5 ( Fig. 5B-III), C-DIM-8 ( Fig. 5B-IV), and more so in C-DIM-5 ( Fig. 5B-V) C-DIM-8 ( Fig. 5B-VI) combinations with doc. There were no variations in body weight (Fig. 5C) or lung (Fig.

However, assays based on reactivity of a single monoclonal antibo

However, assays based on reactivity of a single monoclonal antibody do not correlate quite as well with the other two assays. In particular, it is not uncommon for sera to be negative in a monoclonal antibody competition assay and positive in a less restrictive assay [55] and [57]. A likely

explanation for this observation is that the dominant antibody response in some individuals is to epitopes that do not overlap with the epitope recognized by the competing monoclonal antibody [58]. Regardless of the assay used, studies in young women have demonstrated consistent, strong, and durable antibody responses to each type in the vaccine. Seroconversion rates approach or equal 100% for each type in the vaccines [31], [57], [59] and [60]. Peak geometric mean titers (GMTs) one month after the third dose were at least 100-fold higher than after selleck screening library natural infection and then decline approximately 10-fold to a plateau level in the next 2 years. Virtually all women maintain stable detectable responses for more than 4 years. For Cervarix®, maintenance of plateau levels above the levels detected after

natural infection for up to 8.4 years have been observed [31] and [61] (Fig. 3). Similar results were reported for Gardasil®, with the additional evidence for immune memory in that antibody responses could be boosted by revaccination at month 60 (Fig. Cyclopamine solubility dmso 4) [62]. The notable exception is that about one third of the vaccinees became seronegative for HPV18 in the cLIA assay used in the Gardasil® trials [60]. This exception is more likely due primarily to the HPV18-specific monoclonal antibody not competing effectively with the vaccine-induced antibodies in some women than due to the absence of protective antibodies. Most of the cLIA-negative women were positive in a less restricted assay that measures total VLP IgG, and there is no sign of preferential waning of HPV18 immunity in the Gardasil® trials [57] and [60]. Moreover and importantly Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase there is still protection from HPV18-related disease in these women. There has been one randomized

trial in women 18–45 years old that directly compared the immunogenicity of Gardasil® and Cervarix®. Cervarix® induced significantly higher peak GMTs of neutralizing antibodies than Gardasil®, 2.3–4.8-fold for HPV16 and 6.8–9.1-fold for HPV18, depending upon age [40]. Similar significant differences in HPV16 and HPV18 GMTs for the two vaccines were also observed at month 24 [59]. Higher HPV16/18 VLP-specific IgG levels in the serum of Cervarix® vaccinated women was reflected in correspondingly higher levels of HPV16/18 VLP-specific IgG in cervicovaginal secretions through month 24. The greater antibody (and also T helper) responses to Cervarix® compared to Gardasil® is most likely the result of increase immune activation by the TL4 ligand MPL in the Cervarix®’s AS04 adjuvant [12]. Higher antibody responses would, in general, seem desirable.

There were 18,002 records in the laboratory database of which 17,

There were 18,002 records in the laboratory database of which 17,783 could be matched with the hospital number to the CMS data and included in the analysis. The remaining

219 records were either not within the age range or could not be matched with their hospital number. In the 6M and 18Y groups, NPAs were requested on 2066 (24.8%) and 17,783 (39.4%) admissions (Appendix 7) and were positive in 6.5% (range 4.8–9.9%) and 13.2% (range 9.2–21.5%) during the 6 year period respectively (Appendix 8). Overall 1.6% of admissions in the 6M group and 5.2% in the 18Y group had a positive NPA for influenza (Appendix 7). In both age groups the highest positivity rate was in the 2009/10 period during which time the 2009 pandemic influenza A (H1NI) virus (A(H1N1)pdm09) influenza strain circulated but this effect was less marked in the 6M group Venetoclax cell line (Appendix 8). In all HA hospitals the proportion of all admissions, and the proportion of admissions to general wards and intensive care units, that had a CMS diagnosis of influenza was almost double during the 2009/10 period (Appendix 9). Including all children from 0 days to below 18 years, 1993 had both a laboratory positive result and CMS diagnosis (ICD9-CM 487–487.9) of influenza (Table 1). There were an additional 359 children without a CMS diagnosis of influenza but with

a laboratory confirmed result, and 253 with a LY294002 clinical trial CMS diagnosis of influenza but without laboratory confirmation. This indicates that a CMS diagnosis of influenza under-estimates disease burden relative to the laboratory results despite wide and routine laboratory testing with NPAs in children with fever or respiratory illnesses. Since there appeared to be no obvious age effect (Appendix 3) an overall mean value of 1.05 was used for adjustment factor 1 for all age groups. Of the below 11,063 children

with a primary-respiratory associated diagnosis, 1490 did not have an NPA sent. Adjustment factor 2 assumed the influenza positive rate in these 1490 children was the same as in the 9573 children that had an NPA sent (Table 1). Again this factor did not appear to vary consistently with age and overall mean value of 1.13 was applied to all age groups (Appendix 3). Adjustment factor 3 was the proportion of all admissions by age group that had a laboratory diagnosis of influenza at PWH (Table 1). This factor varied by age group and a smoothed value excluding the first two months was applied to each monthly age group for the complete HA dataset (Appendix 3). The incidence rates of hospitalisation for influenza per 100,000 person-years based on any CMS influenza diagnosis (CMS flu) for the whole of Hong Kong were lowest in the first two months of life, then peaked between 2 and 6 months, and then declined from about 3 to 4 years of age (Fig. 2 and Fig. 3). Similar patterns were observed over the full 6 years of the study.